Volume 18 Issue 241 November 2007
|
Legal Challenges and Practical Constraints; A Comprehensive Study of ‘Community Radio’ in Sri Lanka
|
|
- Thilak Jayaratne, Kishali Pinto-Jayawardena, Dr J de Almeida Guneratne P.C., and Sarath Silva |
| Editors Note ... |
|
This Issue publishes a comprehensive study on the functioning of Community Radio in Sri Lanka which, while examining concerns peculiar to community radio, raises pertinent issues about the very nature and operation of the broadcasting sector in Sri Lanka, particularly regarding issues of licensing by an independent authority.
These are questions that are very relevant at this time, given the arbitrary nature of cancellation and suspension of such licences by the relevant regulatory bodies.
As the Study itself makes clear, the very term’ Community Radio’ (CR) is a misnomer for the types of radio stations that operate ostensibly using this terminology for their functioning. By their very definition, community radio stations are owned and managed by the community. In contrast, the radio stations that function as ‘community radio stations’ in Sri Lanka, even during the time many years back when there was no overt interference by the government, functioned under the aegis of the Sri Lanka Broadcasting Corporation (SLBC). The involvement of the community in the actual operation of the radio station was marginal at best though the efforts taken by individuals at that time to bring about a process of genuine evolution of these stations to serve the needs of the community, needs to be acknowledged and appreciated.
The information gathered from the field visits and the indepth interviews conducted for the purposes of the Study clearly illustrated the utility role that the stations performed at a point in the early stages of their development. However, as the management of the once premier state broadcaster became progressively politicized through the years, the impact that this development had on the vibrant functioning of ‘community radio stations’ was dismal; the case study of the dire consequences that befell once such community radio station in Uva is a good illustration.
There is no doubt that community broadcasting has not been able to justify its encouraging beginnings due to it being submerged within the framework of a politicised SLBC. This is seen by the routine change of its Chairman upon change of political power at elections, the blatant use of SLBC airwaves for party propaganda and the summary rejection of staffers who oppose such propaganda processes. As a result, community radio stations, functioning so far under the aegis of SLBC, have also been exposed to severe political influences that override their objectives.
As the controller attached to the now almost defunct Girandurukotte station lamented, “our interventions (that were earlier commonplace and part of our ordinary functioning) in respect of such basic matters such as retrieving lost identity cards, educating people of the harmful aspects of using aluminium utensils in cooking and the beneficial effect of the consumption of honey and training new settlers with no experience of agriculture and farming, on the essentials of cultivation, have now all been brought to nought.”
A positive feature emerging from the interviews was the acknowledgement by both broadcasters and communities that law/regulatory reform in relation to the regulation/functioning of CR has now become imperative. In a context where legal questions are often thought of as esoteric and far removed from ordinary people, increased awareness of the law and its limitations was a good indication as to the presence of the necessary ground support for change in the legal environment.
The segment of the Study pertaining to the Legal/Regulatory structure of CR assesses the current regulatory/legal framework in relation to the broadcasting regime. It details proposals and recommendations for reform in order to bring about an appropriately enabling legal/regulatory environment for the proper functioning of community radio initiatives within the country.
The analysis is generally referable to the provisions of the Sri Lanka Broadcasting Corporation Act No 37 of 1966 (as amended) in the context of judicial decisions that have attempted to define the parameters within which such a regime should operate together with ancillary legislation such as the Telecommunications Act, No 25 of 1991 (as amended by Act, No 27 of 1996). The workings of these laws are examined in the context of legislative provisions in regard to devolution of power through the 13th Amendment to the Constitution.
The Study also looks at other developments that have impacted on this process, particularly the reports of domestic and international committees that have examined these same issues in the past.
It includes a separate segment analysing elections law as applicable to the electronic media, given that this is a very relevant point of time at which external pressures, (due to malfunctioning governance and electoral processes), may negatively intensify in regard to the functioning of community radio stations, as the case study on Uva Community Radio (UCR) demonstrates.
As the Study shows us, Sri Lanka exemplifies a country where the choice is starkly between a politicised state broadcaster (SLBC) and a largely commercially driven and market operated private broadcasting sector that also operates on (somewhat subtler) political agendas. It is the authors’ view that recommendations in regard to bringing about a more satisfactory regulatory framework insofar as community radio is concerned cannot be considered in isolation from concerns that impact upon private broadcasters or for that matter, the SLBC.
Though the limitations of what could be accomplished in a currently highly tension ridden political environment are conceded, the Study strongly recommends that holistic proposals should address concerns in regard to the entire broadcasting regime in this country.
Even if, in the future, community radio operates on an independent platform, general reform of the broadcasting regime and most vitally, an independent Broadcasting Authority established in line with conditions laid down by Sri Lanka’s Supreme Court in 1997, should accompany or be a condition precedent to bringing about systematic reform of Sri Lanka’s broadcasting culture.
Kishali Pinto-Jayawardena
|
|
- Previous issues - |
Volume 18 Issue 241 November 2007
Legal Challenges and Practical Constraints; A Comprehensive Study of ‘Community Radio’ in Sri Lanka
|
|
- Thilak Jayaratne, Kishali Pinto-Jayawardena, Dr J de Almeida Guneratne P.C., and Sarath Silva
|
Volume 18 Issue 239 & 240 September & October 2007
Raththinde Katupollande Gedara Dingiri Banda vs Sri Lanka
Human Rights Committee - Ninety-First Session
|
|
(15 October to 2 November 2007) Views - Communication No. 1426/2005
|
Reflections on Commissions of Inquiry: How Does Sri Lanka’s Presidential
Commission of Inquiry Compare with International Best Practice?
|
|
Howard Varney
|
Seeing with New Eyes: Looking at Some Mandate Cases with a View to Changing the Approach of Sri Lanka’s Presidential Commission of Inquiry
|
|
Dulani Kulasinghe
|
Second Submission to the Presidential Commission of Inquiry and the public on Human Rights Violations in Sri Lanka: January – August 2007
|
|
Law & Society Trust, the Civil Monitoring Commission and the Free Media Movement
|
Discussion Paper on a Human Rights Field Presence in Sri Lanka
|
|
International Commission of Jurists
|
The Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka; Sombre Reflections and a Critical Evaluation
|
|
-Law & Society Trust
|
Concerns Raised by the Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Manfred Novak
|
|
Mission Visit to Sri Lanka, 1st to 8th October 2007
|
Book Review - The Protection of Culture, Cultural Heritage and Cultural Property by Justice A. R. B. Amerasinghe
|
|
Judge C.J. Weeramantry
|
Volume 17 Issue 238 August 2007
The Sixth Parliament of The Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka (Second Session)
|
|
Interim Report - From the Select Committee of Parliament to look into the Operation of the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution
|
A Promise Unfulfilled: A Critical Scrutiny of the The National Police Commission of Sri Lanka
|
|
Kishali Pinto Jayawardena
|
The Impact of Global Terrorism on Human Rights; Examining Issues Pertaining to Detention and the Change in Usage of Force in International Relations
|
|
Ashan Wickramasinghe
|
Volume 17 Issue 237 July 2007
Gendering the Law
|
|
Priya Thangarajah
|
Women in ‘Business’ (Dhanda): A Historical Survey
|
|
Ponni Arasu
|
Buddhism and Domestic Violence
|
|
Ouyporn Khuankaew
|
Volume 17 Issue 236 June 2007
The Eradication of Laws Delays – Report of the Committee
Appointed to Recommend Amendments to the Practice and
Procedure in Investigations and Courts - 02nd April 2004
|
‘Laws Delays’: Some Perspectives
|
|
Frank de Silva
|
‘Law’s Delays’: Some Further Perspectives….
|
|
Basil Fernando
|
The Malimath Committee on Reforms of the Indian Criminal Justice System: Its Contents and a Critique
|
|
Jananeethi, India and Asian Human Rights Commission, Hong Kong -
|
Volume 17 April & May2007 Joint Issue 234 & 235
A ‘Praxis’ Perspective on Subverted Justice and the Deterioration of Rule of Law Norms in Sri Lanka
|
|
Kishali Pinto Jayawardena
|
Judicial Review of the Statutory Powers of the Attorney General in the Prosecutorial Process; Some Thoughts
|
|
Dr Jayantha de Almeida Guneratne
|
A Critique of the Prosecutorial/Judicial System and the
Role of the Attorney General in respect of Prosecutions for
Grave Human Rights Violations
|
|
Samith de Silva
|
Seemanmemeru Pathiranage Shantha Dharmapriya Pathirana v. DIG / Personal Training & Others
|
|
C.A. Writ Application No. 1123/2002, CA Minutes 09.10.2006
|
Draft Bill for the Protection of Victims of Crime and Witnesses
|
Resettlement in the East: Report of a Civil Society Field Mission to Batticaloa, May 2007
|
Volume 17 Issue 233 March 2007
H. Senarath and Others v Chandrika Bandaranaike Kumaratunga and Others
|
|
S.C. (F.R) Application No. 503/2005, SCM 03rd May 2007
|
Law Enforcement Agencies, Partisan Influences and Civic Rights: Domination OR Customer-Orientation?
|
|
Dr. Siri Gamage
|
Criminal Prosecutions under the Intellectual Property Act, No. 36 of 2003; An Analytical Study
|
|
Justice P.H.K. Kulatilake
|
Issues and Challenges Related to Rehabilitation of Tsunami-Affected Communities in Sri Lanka:
a case study of Sagara Place, Panadura
|
|
Dr. Gamini Hitinayake
|
‘Gramaseva Niladharis’ and Issues of Governance; Recent Perspectives
|
|
Malkanthi de Silva and Sanjeewani Perera
|
Position Paper on Key Social Issues for Consideration by Leaders of Religious Communities as Members of the Council of Religions
|
|
Chandra Jayaratne
|
Volume 17 Issue 232 February 2007
Public Health in Sri Lanka; Obstacles in the Prevention of Vector Borne Diseases
|
|
- Dilhara Pathirana -
|
Making the Right to Health a Reality:Legal Strategies for Effective Implementation
|
|
- Iain Byrne
|
People's Charter for Health
|
From a Peoples’ Health Assembly to a Peoples’ Health Movement
|
|
- People’s Health Movement (PHM)
|
Prevention of Mosquito Breeding Bill
|
Volume 17 Issue 231 January 2007
Report of a Fact Finding Mission to the Maldives by the Law and Society Trust, Sri Lanka and the Asian Human Rights Commission, Hong Kong
|
|
(17- 23rd November 2006)
|
Threats to Human Rights Defenders in the Maldives
|
|
- Shahindha Ismail -
|
Report on Press Freedom in the Maldives by
|
|
the Raajje Foundation
|
The Paul Robinson Proposals for Reform of the
Criminal Justice System of the Maldives
|
Volume 17 Issue 230 December 2006
Sri Lanka after the Tsunami: Opportunities lost?
|
|
- Dr Chandra Lekha Sriram
|
Sri Lanka’s Security Dilemma in the Post 1977 Era:
[A Geo-Political Perspective – up to 2004]
|
|
- Chrishmal Warnasuriya
|
Access to Justice – Advocating an Innovative Legal
Approach to Securing Tsunami Reliefs
|
|
- A. Mohammed Farook -
|
Volume 17 Issue 229 November 2006
RIGHT TO INFORMATION; ILLUSIONARY COURT VICTORIES AND ITS CONTINUING DENIAL
|
|
-Kishali Pinto Jayawardena -
|
WHISTLE BLOWING AND CORRUPTION; AN INITIAL AND COMPARATIVE REVIEW
|
|
-Kirstine Drew -
|
PROMOTING PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY IN OVERSEAS DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE: HARNESSING THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION
|
|
-Charmaine Rodrigues -
|
Volume 17 September & October Joint Issue - 227 & 228
Singarasa v the Attorney General (The Singarasa Case)SCM 15.09.2006
Petition
Judgement of the Supreme Court
Written Submissions
|
The Singarasa Case – A Brief Comment
- RKW Goonesekere -
|
Comment on the Singarasa Case Relating to the Status of the International Covenant on Civil & Political Rights in Sri Lankan Law
|
|
- John Cerone -
|
Human Rights Committee - Lalith Rajapakse v Sri Lanka
CCPR/C/83/D/1250/2004 - 14th July 2006
The Petition
The Decision
|
Response by Counsel on Behalf of the Author to the
Submission from the Government of Sri Lanka in re the Views of the Human Rights Committee in Fernando v Sri Lanka
|
|
CCPR/C/83/D/1189/2003- 31st March 2005
|
Sri Lanka: Recourse to the Optional Protocol as a means
to Redress the Degeneration of the Rule of Law
|
|
- Basil Fernando -
|
Volume 17 Issue 226 August 2006
MIGRANTS’ CHILDREN: MAKING SENSE OF THEIR DEVELOPMENT AND WELFARE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ‘ATTACHMENT
THEORY’
|
|
Sajeewa Samaranayake
|
LEFT BEHIND, LEFT OUT:
The Impact on Children and Families of Mothers Migrating for Work Abroad
|
|
Save the Children in Sri Lanka
|
Volume 16 Issue 225 July 2006
ELEVENTH ANNUAL MEETING OF THE
ASIA PACIFIC FORUM (APF) OF NATIONAL
HUMAN RIGHTS INSTITUTIONS
Suva, Fiji, July-August 2006
|
|
-CONCLUDING STATEMENT
|
Defending the Defenders: Role of National Human
Rights Institutions in protecting and supporting
human rights defenders in Asia
|
Asian NGO proposal to the 11th Annual Meeting of the APF
Suva, Fiji, July-August 2006
|
South Asian Human Rights Defenders'
Declaration 2006 (The Dhulikhel Declaration)
|
One Step Forward and Two Steps Backwards:
The Problematic Functioning of Sri Lanka’s National
Human Rights Commission (NHRC)
|
|
Kishali Pinto Jayawardena
|
Report of the Law and Society Trust in Addressing
Dilemmas of Empowerment at Local Government Level;
The Manifold Problems that Citizens face in
“Going to the Grama Niladhari”
|
A Holistic Approach to Human Rights Education
|
|
Sajeeva Samaranayake
|
Volume 16 Issue 224 June 2006
Representations of the Law and Society Trust to
The Select Committee of Parliament on Reforms to
Parliamentary, Provincial and Local Government
Elections Laws
|
Public Interest Law Foundation and Another v
Hon. Attorney General and Others
Court of Appeal Application No: 1396/2003
CA Minutes 17/12/2003
|
Dr. A.C. Visvalingam and Another v
The Hon. Attorney General,
Court of Appeal Application No: 668/2006
CA Minutes 2/06/2006
|
Court Judgements, Decisions of the Election Commission
and controversies over the Electoral Roll in Bangladesh
|
|
Dr Badiul Alam Majumdar
|
The People v The Federal Attorney General;
In the Matter of the Independence of Nigeria's
National Human Rights Commission
|
|
A Report by the Nigerian Human Rights Community
|
Volume 16 Joint Issue 222 & 223 April & May 2006
LINKAGES BETWEEN TRADE, DEVELOPMENT
AND POVERTY: SRI LANKA
|
|
Dushni Weerakoon and Jayanthi Thennekoon
|
DEVELOPMENT; DO PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT?
|
|
Rukshana Nanayakkara
|
THE DRAFT NATIONAL AUDIT ACT
|
SOME REFLECTIONS ON THE DRAFT
NATIONAL AUDIT ACT
|
|
J C Weliamuna
|
THE LIMA DECLARATION OF GUIDELINES
ON AUDITING PRECEPTS
|
|
Dr Franz Fiedler
|
THE DRAFT RECONSTRUCTION AND
DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ACT
|
SOME REFLECTIONS ON THE DRAFT RADA ACT
|
|
Sarath Fernando
|
Volume 16 Issue 221 March 2006
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS, INCLUDING THE QUESTION OF DISAPPEARANCES AND SUMMARY EXECUTIONS
|
|
Report of the United Nations Special Rapporteur On Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions, Philip Alston - MISSION TO SRI LANKA (28 NOVEMBER TO 6 DECEMBER 2005)
|
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS, INCLUDING THE QUESTION OF RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE
|
|
Report of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief Asma Jahangir- MISSION TO SRI LANKA (2 MAY TO 12 MAY 2005)
|
Volume 16 Issue 220 February 2006
Mohamed and Another v. President of Republic of South Africa and Others
|
|
Winston P. Nagan and Craig Hammer
| | | | | |